alternatehistory.com
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New profile posts
New threadmarks
Latest activity
Members
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Word Count:
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Members
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Marthabutt's latest activity
Marthabutt
reacted to
Garrison's post
in the thread
Republican Spain in WW2 and the Cold War
with
Like
.
To what possible end? Stalin generally acted from cold strategic calculation when it came to foreign policy.
Thursday at 4:42 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
Derek Pullem's post
in the thread
Republican Spain in WW2 and the Cold War
with
Like
.
Because Germany just invaded his only friendly nation in Western Europe? Turning it around Germany may not invade Republican Spain for...
Thursday at 4:41 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
Garrison's post
in the thread
Republican Spain in WW2 and the Cold War
with
Like
.
The Germans can invade Spain successfully, but it will create serious problems. Firstly Vichy is technically neutral, letting the...
Thursday at 4:40 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
raharris1973's post
in the thread
Republican Spain in WW2 and the Cold War
with
Like
.
This still wouldn't all be super easy and friction free. This forces the Wehrmacht into western/southwestern European uninterrupted...
Thursday at 4:40 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
EasternRomanEmpire's post
in the thread
Republican Spain in WW2 and the Cold War
with
Like
.
They could try but Salazar wasn't a big fan of Hitler and Mussolini IIRC, his right-wing dictatorship being very different from fascist...
Thursday at 4:40 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
Lalli's post
in the thread
Republican Spain in WW2 and the Cold War
with
Like
.
Spain after SCW would be really vulnerable and weak so if Hitler indeed wants (probably) invade Spain it shouldn't be difficult even if...
Thursday at 4:40 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
BeardedHoplite's post
in the thread
Republican Spain in WW2 and the Cold War
with
Like
.
Germany definitely uses the momentum after 1940 to invade Spain and overthrow the Republic. Even with the Spanish terrain the invasion...
Thursday at 4:39 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
Garrison's post
in the thread
What might've happened if the Allies didn't exist, and the countries within never declared war on the axis?
with
Like
.
Sorry but you are wrong here, reclaiming Alsace-Lorraine and destroying the French army were prerequisites for turning east, the intent...
Thursday at 4:38 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
Garrison's post
in the thread
What might've happened if the Allies didn't exist, and the countries within never declared war on the axis?
with
Like
.
There was no alliance in 1939 and all that really united the British and the French was the security guarantee to Poland. Once Germany...
Thursday at 4:38 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
THE KINGFISH's post
in the thread
How Cooked was Rhodesia Actually?
with
Like
.
The only way Rhodesia survives is if Zimbabwe Rhodesia survives. But even that's an extreme if.
Thursday at 3:10 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
tus3's post
in the thread
How Cooked was Rhodesia Actually?
with
Like
.
There exist example of Communist countries placing realpolitik above ideology when making alliances. *cough* Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact...
Thursday at 3:08 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
AlexanderDragon's post
in the thread
How Cooked was Rhodesia Actually?
with
Like
.
Rhodesia was doomed from Independence more or less, unless you can come up with a way for the Portuguese to keep the war going(american...
Thursday at 3:07 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
rfmcdonald's post
in the thread
How Cooked was Rhodesia Actually?
with
Like
.
Quite. The Soviets could come up with arguments in favour of imperialism, notably in praising Soviet rule in Central Asia as a...
Thursday at 3:07 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
sampleswift's post
in the thread
How Cooked was Rhodesia Actually?
with
Like
.
No, not going to happen. Soviets were big fans of decolonization and would have seen Rhodesia as a British Imperial relic.
Thursday at 3:05 PM
Marthabutt
reacted to
Warthog's post
in the thread
How Cooked was Rhodesia Actually?
with
Like
.
They were "cooked" when they decided, years after most African countries had majority rule, that they wanted to maintain white supremacy...
Thursday at 3:05 PM
Members
Top