Search results for query: *

Forum search Google search

  1. No WWII Unconditional Surrender

    Thee user clearly stated that he has a grudge towards whole ethnic group If you want to use wiki: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-slavism Slavic people are various ethnic and national groups with their own cultures, not 'a culture'.

  2. Which country if Russian Revolution fails would become communist ?

    Collective system, opposition to capitalism that went with colonialism, promise of a better world. Such ideas would be attractive to people who experienced hardship and brutal version of capitalism.

  3. Which country if Russian Revolution fails would become communist ?

    Could communism be implemented in some of the countries also seeing violent upheavel, like those in colonial empires ?

  4. No WWII Unconditional Surrender

    Being against policies of one state is one thing, being against a whole religious groups and whole national ones is racist. My point that Irioths scenario A would would mean minimum 30 million people murdered, with 50 million being more likely and above 60 million possible if high estimates, was...

  5. Which country if Russian Revolution fails would become communist ?

    If Russian Revolution failed which other country could become the first communist state ? For example was it possible for India after decolonisation ?

  6. No WWII Unconditional Surrender

    Why should Nazism switch to that and not North Korea like totalitarian regime ? But let us see some results of your scenario. During WW2 Nazis killed circa 16 % of Polish population within 5 years, and 13 % of Soviet population in 4 years. Now the Soviet losses are inflicted by much of the...

  7. Map Thread IV

    More details please. Interesting what time it is ? From 2008 to 1992 would make interesting scenario.

  8. What if Europe discovers the America's 200 year earlier.

    moetah-based on my personal interest in the area and history, I think your expectations can't be fulfilled. The cultures of America were on early pre-bronze age level of development(rough assumption, I know their were areas with specialised metallurgy especially regarding ornaments). It would...

  9. Germany demands unconditional surrender

    It kinda fits with the Nazi's Germany ironic stupidity and their relationship with conquered nations.

  10. Germany demands unconditional surrender

    Germany didn't bother with any surrender demands to Poland, Soviet Union, Jews. The policy was: exterminate.

  11. Best Possible outcome for Germnay in WW2

    Lend Lease never kept Russia from starving.:rolleyes: It was usefull but not critical. If Roosvelt(who you mentioned as being object of your hate) and Churchill are 'rabid dogs' as you like to call Allied leaders who fought against Nazi Germany then what are the Germans who wanted to...

  12. No WWII Unconditional Surrender

    That was never the intention of the plan. The idea that it was planned genocide to my knowledge is the brain child of revisionists. So you are in belief only Western Europe is important ? Letting openly betray Eastern Europe means a diplomatic disaster that will make Western Allies lose face...

  13. Best Possible outcome for Germnay in WW2

    Best outcome ? Germany doesn't win so quickly in Poland in 1939, France intervenes, German military overthrows Hitler, state of things returns to before 1939 with small exceptions Czech Republic restored, Gdansk to Germany, minor corrections in both ways in Polish-German border. In 10 to 20...

  14. A sensible Versailles Treaty

    Just as well areas ceded by German in the East were part of German Empire but not actually German, the local population wanted to get out of the oppressive state that discriminated them-see Poznan and Silesia Uprisings. Finland, the baltic states and Ukraine wanted to get out of the empire(and...

  15. A sensible Versailles Treaty

    First you would have to define what sensible means. Borders based on ethnic lines ? Preventing another war ? Not angering several nationalities ? Giving Poland Lithuania isn't sensible btw-simple access to sea is not a goal itself, the area in Pomorze was the exit point for majority of Polish...

  16. Pax Gallicana [LONG!]

    Interesting timeline, I agree. For reason Napoleonic victory ATL's are rare.

  17. Holding Out for a Hero: Gustav Stresemann Survives

    None of the possibilites I proposed speak about Germany losing the war with Soviets. Although I agree that it isn't likely. Other solutions exist like Socialist revolution in Germany and German Socialist Republic joing Soviet Union on its own during war in Europe. The possibility IV could...

  18. Long-term consequences of a Napoleonic victory?

    More socialism, more liberal society, you would also had more ethnic minorities from Africa in Europe. With unified Europe better infrastructure connecting countries, and more class debates as industralisation grows. Maybe earlier socialist revolution ?

  19. Holding Out for a Hero: Gustav Stresemann Survives

    Foreign Shadow-only Possibility I out IV has Poland as surviving independent state. It is kind of funny when considered- a suriving Poland is Polandwank :p

  20. Peaceful revision of Germany's Polish border, 1921-1933

    The German army was around 100,000 while the Poles could have around 1,000,000. True Germany would likely mobilize more for war. But such mobilisation would likely change the French neutrality and would take so long that Poles could even take preventive attack or prepare in other ways. Also as...
Top