The premise is simple we take the original results of Wrestlemania I the granddaddy of all pay per views (even though it was on cctv) and flip them. Everyone who won their match lost and everyone who lost their match won. Then take that information and create new matches and story lines based on that one changed night. It's arguably the night that created the modern wrestling era and as Wrestlemania 2020 is nearly upon us here's a fun thought exercise. Create a fantasy world you'd like to watch. Take it all the way to Wrestlemania 2 if you like.
Madison Square Garden
New York City, New York
March 31, 1985
The Executioner def. Tito Santana via pinfall (Using the DDT or as he called it the Las Vegas Jackpot)
S.D. Jones def. King Kong Bundy (w/Jimmy Hart) via pinfall (In 9 seconds via a surprise roll up)
Matt Osborne def. Ricky Steamboat via pinfall (Reversing the Dragon's High Cross Body)
Brutus Beefcake (w/Johnny Valiant) vs. David Sammartino (w/Bruno Sammartino) remains the same with a double dq.
Greg Valentine (w/Jimmy Hart) def. Junkyard Dog via pinfall (Original finish with Valentine's feet on the ropes. Retains Intercontinental Championship)
The U.S. Express (Mike Rotundo and Barry Windham w/Lou Albano) def. Nikolai Volkoff and The Iron Sheik (w/Freddie Blassie) via pinfall (Sheik accidentally hits Volkoff with Freddie Blassie's cane. Windham pins. Retaining the World Tag Titles.)
Big John Studd (w/Bobby Heenan) def. Andre the Giant in a bodyslam challenge. Career vs $15,000. (Thanks to the cheating of Bobby Heenan. Crowd stunned. Chanting thank you Andre as he walks off. Studd pretends to throw money to the crowd while laughing.)
Leilani Kai (w/Fabulous Moolah) def. Wendy Richter (w/Cyndi Lauper) via pinfall. (Kai retains the WWF Women's title with a flying crossbody. Rumor has it Moolah influenced the outcome backstage.)
Paul Orndorff and Roddy Piper (w/Bob Orton) def Hulk Hogan and Mr. T (w/ Jimmy Snuka) via pinfall. Guest Referees Muhammad Ali and Pat Patterson. (Orndorff pins Hogan after interference from Bob Orton. Hogan, Snuka, and Mr. T Hulk up and clear the ring afterwards to stand tall promising the crowd they'd get their win back.)
Madison Square Garden
New York City, New York
March 31, 1985
The Executioner def. Tito Santana via pinfall (Using the DDT or as he called it the Las Vegas Jackpot)
S.D. Jones def. King Kong Bundy (w/Jimmy Hart) via pinfall (In 9 seconds via a surprise roll up)
Matt Osborne def. Ricky Steamboat via pinfall (Reversing the Dragon's High Cross Body)
Brutus Beefcake (w/Johnny Valiant) vs. David Sammartino (w/Bruno Sammartino) remains the same with a double dq.
Greg Valentine (w/Jimmy Hart) def. Junkyard Dog via pinfall (Original finish with Valentine's feet on the ropes. Retains Intercontinental Championship)
The U.S. Express (Mike Rotundo and Barry Windham w/Lou Albano) def. Nikolai Volkoff and The Iron Sheik (w/Freddie Blassie) via pinfall (Sheik accidentally hits Volkoff with Freddie Blassie's cane. Windham pins. Retaining the World Tag Titles.)
Big John Studd (w/Bobby Heenan) def. Andre the Giant in a bodyslam challenge. Career vs $15,000. (Thanks to the cheating of Bobby Heenan. Crowd stunned. Chanting thank you Andre as he walks off. Studd pretends to throw money to the crowd while laughing.)
Leilani Kai (w/Fabulous Moolah) def. Wendy Richter (w/Cyndi Lauper) via pinfall. (Kai retains the WWF Women's title with a flying crossbody. Rumor has it Moolah influenced the outcome backstage.)
Paul Orndorff and Roddy Piper (w/Bob Orton) def Hulk Hogan and Mr. T (w/ Jimmy Snuka) via pinfall. Guest Referees Muhammad Ali and Pat Patterson. (Orndorff pins Hogan after interference from Bob Orton. Hogan, Snuka, and Mr. T Hulk up and clear the ring afterwards to stand tall promising the crowd they'd get their win back.)