Going Underground: The Story of Wrestling Society X

An Extreme Termination
An Extreme Termination

"I said 'You wanna fire him? Then you're gonna have to fire me too, because I'm not firing this kid.' Then they fired me."

- Paul Heyman in a 2012 interview​

October 2005 was a surprising month for wrestling fans, as news hit the wire that WWE fired Paul Heyman, a revered creative mind who had run ECW back in the mid-to-late ‘90s. As the story goes, Heyman had been sent down to work in WWE’s developmental territory, Ohio Valley Wrestling. At OVW, he first met indie darling CM Punk and the two became close friends.

However, despite Heyman’s crowing about Punk’s talents, WWE had no interest in him and said that not only were there no plans to put him on WWE television, but they saw him as not deserving to be on OVW television. The top brass at WWE wanted Punk fired, but Heyman wouldn’t budge. The arguments between Heyman and Vince soon tipped over and finally, Heyman was fired along with CM Punk.

Many speculated over Heyman’s future in wrestling, suspecting he would soon join TNA in a booking capacity. However, Heyman stayed quiet on matters for some time, but during those many months, he and Kevin Kleinrock, the former vice president of California-based XPW, were steeped in negotiations with MTV.

Kleinrock, now working for Big Vision Entertainment, had met Heyman in passing a few times and eventually got into contact with him to see if he wanted in on Kleinrock’s new venture; a wrestling TV show designed with a gritty, underground fight club aesthetic. Heyman, now free of the WWE and with a top-tier talent in need of work, took Kleinrock up on his offer.

Heyman, who was often just as much a smooth talker behind the curtain as he was on camera, was able to iron out some of the finer details and demands that MTV was bringing to them. He managed to nix their plans for pyrotechnics and special effects, though in exchange allowed the network to put attractive plants in the front row seats.

The network wanted to control the style of wrestling, citing fears of imitation after similar incidents plagued Beavis and Butthead. Heyman was able to argue for a late night slot, arguing that 9 PM eastern would be late enough that kids were either in bed or having dinner and wouldn’t be able to watch the show, and that the slot would still catch the coveted 18-24 male demo they were hoping for. He also managed to argue for a single hour of running time and talked the execs into giving them Wednesday nights. In exchange, Heyman agreed to their choice of comedian Bret Ernst on commentary opposite Kleinrock’s choice of XPW play-by-play Kris Kloss.

Being this was MTV, there was a push for musicians to play a part in the show. Heyman quickly worked that out by agreeing to feature live performances if the company allowed them four yearly two-hour live specials, promising that the artists would be given time on those shows for performances.

Negotiations lasted for many weeks, only getting pen to paper in January 2006, but soon enough, Heyman and Kleinrock were able to get a TV deal out of MTV and with their connections, were able to wrangle up a decently-sized roster of wrestlers. On February 10, they would tape their first episode, which was set to air on the following Wednesday.

That Wednesday, February 15, the debut episode of WSX: Underground was aired on MTV.

No one had any idea just how big this was going to be.
 
WSX Roster
WSX Roster

(Note: The following roster is currently what I'd consider a minimum number. I didn't want to stray too far from the actual number of signed talent and wanted to keep the number low since WSX is still a small league at this stage in time. I am willing to consider another 10-20 signings, but I wouldn't hold me to that.)


  1. 6-Pac
  2. Aaron Aguilera
  3. Alkatrazz
  4. Arik Cannon
  5. Babi Slymm
  6. B-Boy
  7. Bubba Ray
  8. Chris Hamrick
  9. CM Punk
  10. Colt Cabana
  11. Desmond Wolfe
  12. Devon
  13. Disco Machine
  14. Horiguchi
  15. The Human Tornado
  16. Jack Evans
  17. Jimmy Jacobs
  18. Joey Ryan
  19. Josh Raymond
  20. Justin Credible
  21. Luke Hawx
  22. Matt Sydal
  23. Matt Cross
  24. New Jack
  25. Nigel McGuinness
  26. Puma
  27. Quicksilver
  28. Raven
  29. Rhino
  30. Ricky Banderas
  31. Ruckus
  32. Sabu
  33. Sandman
  34. Scorpio Sky
  35. Teddy Hart
  36. Tommy Dreamer
  37. Tyler Black
  38. Vampiro
  39. Vic Grimes
  40. Yoshino
 
The Road to First Blood
The Road to First Blood

On the inaugural episode of WSX: Underground, the crowd was given three exciting matches; two singles and a tag, both parts of concurrent tournaments for the WSX World and Tag Team Championships. The show had a stripped down, gritty presentation, designed to contrast the more polished spectacle of WWE. Wrestlers were introduced through UFC-style vignettes and matches were fought under no disqualification, anything goes rules, allowing matches liberal use of weapons such as chairs, canes, tables and anything else MTV would allow.

The show began with the most obvious choice to Heyman, CM Punk. Heyman felt great vindication as the crowd hollered for Punk as he made his way down the ramp to face Justin Credible. Punk would win his match, advancing to the quarterfinals of the WSX World Title tournament. Following that was Team 3D (formerly known as the Dudleys) defeating the team of Al Katrazz and Luke Hawx after putting Katrazz through a table. In the main event, Raven defeated the Sandman in an absolute brawl, with Raven grabbing the mic and warning Tommy Dreamer to drop out "if he knows what's good for him."

As the April 26th First Blood supercard drew closer, more tournament matches followed.

April 22, 2006

- 6-Pac d. Matt Sydal
- That '70s Team (Joey Ryan/Disco Machine) d. Team Dragon Gate
- Sabu d. New Jack

March 1, 2006

- Colt Cabana d. Nigel McGuinness
- Do It For Her (Tyler Black/Jimmy Jacobs) d. Aerial Xpress (Quicksilver/Scorpio Sky)
- Ricky Banderas d. Vampiro

March 8, 2006

- Teddy Hart d. Jack Evans
- Keepin' It Gangsta (Ruckus/Babi Slymm) d. The Cartel (Aaron Aguilera/B-Boy)
- Tommy Dreamer d. Rhino

March 15, 2006

- CM Punk d. 6-Pac
- Team 3D d. That '70s Team
- Raven d. Sabu

March 22, 2006

- Colt Cabana d. Teddy Hart
- Keepin' It Gangsta d. Do it For Her
- Tommy Dreamer d. Ricky Banderas

March 29, 2006

- CM Punk d. Colt Cabana
- WSX Tag: Team 3D d. Keepin' It Gangsta (w/New Jack)
- Raven d. Tommy Dreamer

April 5, 2006

- 6-Pac/Justin Credible d. The Sandman/Tommy Dreamer
- The Human Tornado d. Puma
- CM Punk d. Rhino

April 12, 2006

- 6-Pac/Justin Credible d. Arik Cannon/Vic Grimes
- Desmond Wolfe (w/Nigel McGuinness) d. Tyler Black (w/Jimmy Jacobs)
- CM Punk d. Teddy Hart

April 19, 2006

- 6-Pac/Justin Credible d. Keepin' It Gangsta (w/New Jack)
- CM Punk d. Vampiro
- Raven d. Colt Cabana
 
First Blood
WSX First Blood

Date: April 26, 2006
Venue: The WSX Bunker
Announce Team: Kris Kloss/Bret Ernst​

The Filth and the Fury (Teddy Hart/Matt Cross) d. Puma/Jack Evans

Starting off with a high-flying tag team match pitting two former tag partners against each other. Evans brings the young Puma as a partner to face Cross and Teddy. Cross gets the pin on Puma to kick off the show.

Desmond Wolfe (w/Nigel McGuinness) d. Matt Sydal

The more observant of you may notice something amiss here. You may be asking "Who's Desmond Wolfe?" or "Wait, wasn't Nigel McGuinness Desmond Wolfe?" And yes, in OTL he was called that in TNA, but ITTL the moniker goes to a young Geordie by the name of Benjamin Satterly, or as you all might know him, Pac.

Yep, Pac's little visa issue got resolved ITTL and so he was brought in with the storyline being that the older, more experienced Nigel is taking Desmond under his learning tree. But enough of that backstory, we keep up the excitement with high-flying action from Wolfe and Sydal, ending with a corkscrew senton securing Wolfe a win.

Ricky Banderas d. Sabu

Sabu faces off against Banderas,, falling to a Chokeslam through a table. And speaking of tables, here comes the Black Table Society!

Wait... that doesn't sound right, lemme see *checks notes* Oh, I'm sorry, that's the Black Label Society, this is the musical interlude. They're a requirement for these two-hour live shows. Good mood setter for music, though. Gets the crowd going.

Team 3D (c) d. 6-Pac/Justin Credible in a Tables Match for the WSX Tag Team Championship

Well, you ain't dealing with the X-Factor, but Waltman and Credible are tagging, so it's close enough. Just a solid tag title defense, Credible eating 3D through a table.

CM Punk d. Raven for the vacant WSX World Championship

Just have the two do what they want as long as it can pass MTV censors. Punk and Raven know each other well and will bring the noise for this match, ending off with a GTS and Punk securing the win.

Oh yeah, WrestleMania happened this month, didn't it? Well, nothing too much changed there, just Matt Hardy winning Money in the Bank.
 
Last edited:
Their is no way cm punk would ever be caught dead in the same roster as teddy hart. They HATE each other. Going back to ring of honor when teddy showed up concussed and started doing unplanned spots like moonsaults and shooting star presses off a steel cage after a match instead of selling and put other wrestlers in danger. Afterward he and punk got into a fight at a restaurant that sabu to break up.
 
Their is no way cm punk would ever be caught dead in the same roster as teddy hart. They HATE each other. Going back to ring of honor when teddy showed up concussed and started doing unplanned spots like moonsaults and shooting star presses off a steel cage after a match instead of selling and put other wrestlers in danger. Afterward he and punk got into a fight at a restaurant that sabu to break up.

Yeah, that's definitely the hard part and I assume Teddy's days are numbered here, especially with Punk as champ. Heyman was able to talk him into going on board, but first moment I get, Teddy is likely going to be seeing his walking papers.
 
If I may, I'll needa list on who's on the rosters of both wwe and tna but I'd like to throw in some suggestions on who to sLee.
1st yoshihiro Tajiri, I love the Japanese buzzsaw and he could be team dragon gates new master instead of sakoda.
2nd Matt Morgan the blueprint of tna big monster heel.
3rd and 4th Claudio castagnoli and Chris hero Kings of wrestling great indy tag team from the mid to late 2000s, multiple titles from chikara,roh,czw with Larry Sweeney as manager if he's still alive.
5th and 6th el generico and Kevin Steen. AKA Sami zayn and Kevin owens
7th brodie lee. RIP
8th jerry lynn ecw original, helped launch tna x division during the asylum years with aj styles and low ki
9th necro butcher ultraviolet deathmatch specialist. Expect many bloody wars with new jack.
10th 11th and 12th kenny omega and the young bucks the one winged angel and the super kick party
13th tetsuya naito tranquilo, asssenayo
14th 15th 16th and 17th Adam Cole baybay reDRAgon Bobby fish and Kyle o reily and Roderick strong the undisputed era
You don't need to sign all these guys but they where really great workers back in the 2000s who most would go on the the big leagues the next decade and not knowing how big your companies budget is I don't think you can just sign guys like Kurt angle and chris Jericho.
 
Beach Brawl
WSX Beach Brawl

Date: July 26, 2006
Venue: WSX Bunker
Announce Team: Kris Kloss/Bret Ernst​

The Cartel d. Keepin' It Gangsta (w/New Jack)
Ricky Banderas d. Matt Cross


Starting off with all three members of the Cartel getting wins. Yeah, Banderas is joining the Cartel. Feel free to point out how none of the three members (Banderas, Aguilera and B-Boy) are the same nationality like that's ever stopped wrestling from doing awkward stereotyped foreign heel groups like this.

Also, we got Mil Muertes vs. Son of Havoc, for those of you who follow your OTL wrestling.

Jack Evans d. Teddy Hart in a Loser Leaves the Bunker Match

I mean, this was gonna happen sooner or later. Teddy's antics probably rubbed someone backstage the wrong way, be it Punk, Heyman, about 50% of the WSX locker room, or the MTV brass. Take your pick, really. But the feud between him and former partner Jack Evans closes here with Jack getting the win and sending Teddy out of WSX. Bye, Teddy! You were a pain in the ass!

Musical Interlude: Breaking Point

Tonight's interlude brought by Breaking Point, who play Show Me a Sign, All Messed Up and... One of a Kind.

Huh...

Team 3D (c) d. Rhino/Lil' Spike D for the WSX Tag Team Championship

So, Paul's sneaky little way around WWE's whole copyright of the Dudley name is pretty simple. They're not the Dudleys, they're Team 3D, Bubba Ray D, Devon D and Lil' Spike D. If you don't say what the "D" stands for, then Vince can't sue. If this is too unrealistic for you, we'll just use their TNA names, though I'm not a fan of those.

Meanwhile, Spike comes in with intent to take the tag titles from his brothers and enlists former enemy Rhino to help him, but the older brothers keep and put Little Spike through a table for his troubles.

CM Punk (c) d. Sabu for the WSX World Championship

An odd mix of styles, but I can imagine Punk can do something Sabu to make this work. Punk hits the GTS to win, throws the belt over his shoulder and then points to himself with his thumbs, chanting "C. M. Punk."

Huh... that's an odd gesture... and him beating Sabu for the title... wait a minute...

Then, just as it seems things are about to end, the speakers switch from Punk's music to... One of a Kind...

Wait, hang on...

Rob Van Dam then rushes the ring and blasts Punk with a chair. When Punk turns around, he's hit with a Van Daminator and drops to the mat, chair still on his chest as RVD goes up and hits a Five Star Frog Splash.

Van Dam ends the show by throwing belt over his shoulder and doing the taunt himself.

"R. V. D."
 
Last edited:
Hallowicked
WSX Hallowicked

Date: October 25, 2006
Venue: The Rave in Milaukee, Wisconsin
Attendance: 5,000
Announce Team: Joey Styles/Bret Ernst​

Opening Act: Twiztid

Ladies and gentlemen, Wrestling Society X and the Insane Clown Posse present WSX Hallowicked! Make some noise!

That's right, the ICP are doing some cross promotion with WSX, getting them the booking for their first non-Bunker show. It's a loaded house for a first run out of Cali, helped by the Juggalo faithful and the announced main of CM Punk vs. RVD.

This time, our featured musical act is Twiztid, who kick things off to pump up the live crowd.

The Cartel d. The Insane Clown Posse

In our opening match, the ICP play punching for the Cartel. They get the stuffing beat out of them, Shaggy eating the pin.

Rhino d. Lil' Spike D

Spike's alliance with Rhino fell apart, leading to this match. Do a crowd surf spot because that's fun. Gore folds him in half.

Team 3D (c) d. Vampiro/Raven for the WSX Tag Team Championship

We get a Dead Pool reunion here at WSX. Some good hardcore fun with Vampiro going through the table.

Tyler Black d. 6-Pac, The Human Tornado, Jack Evans, Matt Sydal and Puma in a Six-Man Ladder Match for the WSX Television Championship

We add a midcard belt to the mix. Everyone in his match won a qualifier to get a spot. 6-Pac beat his buddy Justin Credible, HT beat Joey Ryan, Evans beat Matt Cross, Sydal beat Desmond Wolfe, Puma got the upset win over Ricky Banderas and as for Tyler Black...

Let me tell you the story of Do It For Her. The story of two young, handsome, high-flying heartthrob babyfaces. The girls swooned for them, but for Jimmy Jacobs, there was only one girl he wanted.

That was Lacey, WSX's backstage interviewer. Jimmy loved Lacey. Whatever he would do, he'd do it for her. But, as Tommy Wiseau said, love is blind. Jimmy's love blinded him to many things, most importantly his tag partner's mounting frustration.

Jimmy's affection had been used against the team, costing them title matches, costing them titles and while Tyler Black was gaining popularity and momentum, Jimmy fell short against guys like Sydal and Joey Ryan, who used his feelings for Lacey to get the upper hand on him.

It all came to a head at the qualifier between Jacobs and Black, where, after securing the win, Tyler chin-checked his partner with a superkick. The two would meet on the next Underground on Joey Ryan's talk show, the Magnum Motel, where they shook hands, hugged it out... then Black hit Jimmy with another superkick. Jacobs, for his part, dove through the motel window in an act of Jannetty-like cowardice. Tyler then grabbed a mic and declared that from then on he wasn't gonna do it for her.

"I do it for me!"

The match is the fun, bump-crazy ladder match you always get with this set-up. Finish comes with Sydal hitting a Shooting Star Press and wiping everyone but Black and Puma out.

The two meet at the top of a ladder, fighting each other until Black rips off a piece of Puma's mask. Puma covers face, giving Black an opening to send him off and unhook the belt.

CM Punk (c) Rob Van Dam for the WSX World Championship

The crowd is on their feet as the two men tear the house down. Story is simple enough, RVD wants the belt and Punk has the belt. Maybe sprinkle in some real life by having Punk bring up Van Dam's arrest for drug possession that got him fired from WWE. Punk's not a full heel, maybe a tweener, but by the end, the crowd are chanting his name as he hits the GTS and gets the win.

Paul Heyman made Punk a world champion, Raven made him a main eventer, but tonight, Rob Van Dam made him a star.
 
Last edited:
So, what's going on with WWE, you may be wondering?

Well, the way I see things is that for the most part, I don't have much to cover. My standing idea is that anyone who got called up to ECW pretty much stayed in developmental until whenever they OTL joined one of the main two brands and really, anyone drafted to ECW was essentially going to Smackdown anyway. If a wrestler never switched from ECW to another brand, they instead will get released.

The only major change is Matt Hardy cashing in on Edge at Vengeance, though he would have to relinquish the title after remnants of a staph infection were found.
 
Well I know its inevitable to ask, but how is TNA reacting to WSX? Because Samoa Joe, Austin Aries, and Rodrick Strong are still part timers for them and ROH. according to the wwe's documentary on him, Heyman suggested Joe as his number 2 after Punk and the 60 minute draw is still in the smart mark's mind as the best match of all time.
 
Well I know its inevitable to ask, but how is TNA reacting to WSX? Because Samoa Joe, Austin Aries, and Rodrick Strong are still part timers for them and ROH. according to the wwe's documentary on him, Heyman suggested Joe as his number 2 after Punk and the 60 minute draw is still in the smart mark's mind as the best match of all time.

Man, I should've popped in earlier, but to answer, there are a few possibilities.

Strong was actually fired by TNA after an incident where he and Aries stuck to their ROH commitments while risking missing Against All Odds 2006 (Aries would be suspended) so there's always a chance of them coming in.

With Joe, I'll say that 2008 is gonna be a big year for the bunker.

At this point, I wanna say TNA isn't too worried about them. They've been willing to loan a few names to work with Paul, mainly Team 3D and some other ex-ECW guys.
 
Top