What was so special about the Tang

As most of us know, Tang China was a powerhouse, reached farther than any other native dynasty and ushered in a golden age.

My question is, what allowed the Tang to build an empire unrivaled elsewhere in Chinese History, why did they push into the steppe rather than stay in their borders? What made them so expansionist?
 
Firstly, in terms of Empire size the Tang was not the largest in Chinese history - that honor belongs to the Qing (or Yuan).

Couple of reasons:

1) Most importantly: legacy of the Sui, the 38-year dynasty that preceded China. The Sui not only unified China and put an end to a 300-year-long unrest, but it also made the realm more productive as a whole. Emperor Wen of Sui's 'recovery' policies stored huge surpluses which his son, Emperor Yang, used for massive projects such as the refurbishment of the Guanzhong region (Luoyang), and the building of the Grand Canal. Such projects caused unrest which eventually brought down the Sui, but it provided an ideal foundation for the Tang economy (greater north-south integration, revitalization of the critical Wei River Valley), which China could use as influence against its periphery.

2) Tang open-ness: the Tang were rather open as a culture (maybe because the Li clan was semi-Turkic), and under their rule China was relatively open to foreigners. There's the standard 'tolerance of religions' edicts, Arab enclaves in the southern ports etc., but more importantly the Tang was pretty open to non-Han holding government positions, even military positions. For example, An Lushan, the most famous Tang military commander or jiedushi (for all the wrong reasons), was half-Sogdian. Epitaph research for the Tang also demonstrates the existence of Tibetan commanders and so on. Evidently if you're willing to include foreigners in your hierarchy you have a better chance of bringing said foreigners under your rule.

3) Nomadic weakness: traditionally the greatest limiting factor for Chinese military power came from the steppe nomads, which if unified could cause massive headaches for Emperors (as they did during the Song and Ming). The dominant steppe power during the Sui-Tang period was the Gokturk Khanate, which during the Sui Dynasty had split into two warring halves. Various future steppe powers, such as the Jurchens or the Khitans, were not yet capable of filling in the void. This left a strategic vacuum in both Mongolia and East Turkestan, which the Tang Dynasty could easily fill in with little effort.

4) Tang governance: unlike the traditional view of Imperial Chinese governance, pre-Song China was largely governed by aristocrats who derived their influence from extensive estates in their place of origin - kind of like the UK during the 18thC, I suppose. Normally this is a recipe for disaster, as local notables gradually become independent of central authority and become powers in their own right (a major contributor of unrest during the period between the Han and Sui).

Various reforms in the Tang and Sui helped re-focus power back in the hands of the Central Government, such as the examinations system (which was still largely dominated by the aristocracy during this period), the elevation of the Imperial capital as a place for the rich and powerful to live, and a clearer delineation of the Emperor's responsibilities vis-à-vis his aristocratic officials. As such, the Tang avoided the short-and-powerless fate of its predecessor dynasties.

5) Tang culture: part of what made the Tang 'great' was the explosion of culture that happened during the period, with poets such as Li Bai, Du Fu, and so on. In a sense this phenomenon was a result of Tang openness (and also the fact that imperial examinations included literary tests), with increased contact with foreign cultural output forcing changes in how China developed its own literary form. Chief among this was the abandonment of the extremely formulaic and conservative pianwen form, the dominant literary output during the Northern and Southern Dynasties, for more free-wheeling, 'Romantic' poetry as exemplified by Li Bai and the others. Similarly, the flowering of Buddhism during this period and subsequent increased contact with India also wrought changes to Tang sculpture and painting, for example in the Mogao Grottoes in Dunhuang.

Basically, the Tang inherited a realm of vast potential from the Sui, and enhanced it further through a liberal willingness to engage with its periphery, an attitude reinforced by the fact that it experienced no real peer competition during the period. No other Chinese dynasty has been so lucky before or since.
 
Last edited:

PhilippeO

Banned
They also lucky in leadership. Li Shi Min while still prince is commander of "Light Cavalry". those method of fighting come from Steppe nomad, and he probably know/have subordinate who is nomad, He have knowledge and understanding of nomad culture to exploit when nomad have weakness.
 
Tang expanded foreign trade to an unprecedented level using both the Silk Road and maritime Silk Road, allowing it to grow rich, export its culture as well as benefit from new ideas and fashions, i.e. sitting in chairs instead on mats like the Japanese. It embraced Buddhism, then a common religion in Greco-Persian Central Asia, which allowed it to plug into a common religious sphere. They were more integrated with foreign empires than any later native Chinese dynasty. When the Abbasids conquered Persia, the entire Persian royal court along with their surviving army fled into exile in China as the emperor was family by marriage.

Militarily the Tang cavalry was very powerful and possibly the first to standardize on the stirrup, this allowed them to overcome the advantages nomadic horse armies traditionally had over the Chinese. Horse culture in China reached its apex during the Tang. It's said the game of polo was originally popularized by the Tang and was the favorite pass-time of every aristocrat. (the British introduced polo after observing it played by tribes near the Himalayas) Contrast that with the Qing dynasty where Europeans observed the only people riding horses were Manchus.

Some historians also claimed a climate shift occured during the Tang with Central Asia and north China becoming less agriculturally productive. This would explain China's economic center shifting towards south China during later Tang along with the rise of a very different autarkic agrarian economy instead of the militaristic trade empire it was during early Tang.
 
Last edited:

raharris1973

Gone Fishin'
Firstly, in terms of Empire size the Tang was not the largest in Chinese history - that honor belongs to the Qing (or Yuan).

Yuan and Qing had greater total landmass (having Tibet, which the Tang did not, helped).

Tang dynasty may have been the "widest" of dynasties based on the east-west axis alone:

http://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tang_Dynasty#mediaviewer/File:唐朝疆域(简).png


Yuan dynasty had the greatest extent strictly on the north-south axis - from Siberia's Yenisei river to Burma.
 
I've read somewhere that at some point the Tang Emperor was the Khan of some Confederation past the Chinese borders, anything about that or have I milked this thread long enough?
 
Top